Well, let me be a contrarian on this. Does anyone remember those thick, embossed, clear vinyl seat covers that were popular back in probably the 70s? (Showing my age here.) They were sold, of course, to protect your upholstery, and they most certainly did that. Of course, to do that, they were hot in the summer, cold and stiff in the winter, and pretty much hid the upholstery and looked pretty hideous while doing so. I don't think they're even sold anymore, and its been years, maybe decades since I've seen any.
I view all these hard cases like the Speck and even the Seidio as very similar things. They're ugly, they inhibit the functionality of the BlackBerry (pressing the side buttons is next to impossible, they're recessed so deep on that Speck!) but they most definitely DO protect the BlackBerry from any scratches. Personally, I put an unobtrusive, almost invisible shield on the screen only, keep it holstered when I'm carrying it, and go on about my business.
What's the point of these things after all - to have a prettier BlackBerry, right? Well, sorry, but it looks downright UGLY encased in those things, not prettier at all. So I guess you know in your heart that it looks pretty
under that ugly enclosure, but in the meantime it just looks ugly 24/7!
Mine looks a whole lot better all the time. Sure, eventually it will end up with a few scratches and dings, just like any car does. But in the meantime it looks like its supposed to look like. I end up trading up every year or so anyway, and it doesn't get THAT beat up in a year's time. No thick vinyl aftermarket seatcovers for me, and no ugly hard shell plastic cases for my BlackBerry either!